Showing posts with label anomalies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anomalies. Show all posts

Monday, February 1, 2021

47. Calculating the monthly anomalies using MRTs

Over the next few posts I intend to return to my investigation of the temperature records in Europe by extending my analysis to other countries of the EU besides those of Belgium and the Netherlands that were studied in Post 40 and Post 41 respectively. Central to all these studies is the concept of the temperature anomaly. In many of my previous posts (including Post 4) I have given explanations of how these have been calculated. However, because the data for each country or region tends to have different temporal distributions of data, this has sometimes necessitated using slightly different methods for determining the anomalies of some countries compared to others. So, as this is the start of a new year, I thought this would be a good time to outline exactly how the anomalies are derived, and what drives the decisions to change the methodology from time to time.

The process I use is broadly similar to that used by the main climate science groups (i.e. NOAA, NASA-GISS, Hadley-CRU and Berkeley Earth). However, there are a number of differences, and given how important the analysis process is in terms of its impact on the resulting temperature trend, it therefore seems important that I describe explicitly what I do, and why I do it, not least so that it can be easily referenced in the future.

When studying climate change it is essential that we are able to compare temperature data from different epochs and different locations. There are essentially two problems here. The first is that not all temperature records are of the same length (in terms of time). The second is that the temperatures from different regions can have massively different mean values and ranges of temperature fluctuation.  

For example, Europe has over 100 temperature records that predate 1850 and have over 1800 months of temperature data. The whole of the Southern Hemisphere has two (Rio de Janeiro and Hobart). 

When it comes to temperature ranges and mean values, there are similar extremes. Station records from near the equator (such as Manaus) can have very high mean temperatures of +27 °C with the monthly mean only varying by about ±1 °C across the seasons (such as they are). In contrast, at the South Pole the mean temperature is about -48 °C and the variation of the monthly mean over the year can be ±15 °C or more.

If all temperature records were of the same length, and if all regions of the planet had the same number of stations, these differences would not matter. But because records have different lengths and are often clustered in certain regions, they do. To see how, consider the following.

i) The mathematical basis of the temperature anomaly

In an ideal world we could calculate the change in temperature just by averaging all the temperatures from all the different stations for a given month. If this average was different from month to month then that would be evidence of climate change. We can represent this mathematically as follows.

If Ti(m) is the mean temperature of station i for month m, and Mi is the mean temperature of station i over all time, then

 Ti(m) = Mi + εi(m) 

(47.1)

where εi(m) is the variation of the monthly mean temperature for station i for each different month m (see Post 5 for more explanation of temperature anomalies, weather and climate). The index m has a different integer value for each month of data in the temperature record for that station. So, if the temperature record has 1200 months of data, m will take values from 1 to 1200. 

The term εi(m) in Eq. 47.1 is the temperature anomaly. It is the amount by which the temperature in station record i varies from a reference value, usually taken to be the long term mean temperature, Mi. Now consider what happens when we sum the temperatures for month m from all i station records.

 ∑i Ti(m) = ∑i Mi + ∑i εi(m) 

(47.2)

If we now calculate the average of each term we get the result

 <T(m)> = <M> + <ε(m)>

(47.3)

where <T(m)> is the mean of Ti(m) averaged over all i stations, and repeated for each month m. Similarly, <ε(m)> is the mean of εi(m) averaged over all i stations for each month m, and <M> is the mean of Mi averaged over all i stations for each month m. 

In an ideal world where all temperature records have valid data in each given month m, the term <M> is just a constant that does not vary with the month m. It then follows that the change in the mean temperature <T(m)> from month to month m will be the same as the change in the anomaly <ε(m)> from month to month. So, in an ideal world (where all temperature records are of the same length), averaging all station temperature records should give us the climate change over time.

But we don't live in an ideal world and all temperature records are not of the same length. This means that <M> will not be the same for every month, but will generally be different for different months, depending on how many of the temperature records have data for that month and how many don't. So <M> will vary from month to month. That means it will contribute to (and possibly dominate) the temperature trend over time, and consequently this means that we can't use the average of all temperatures <T(m)> to determine the temperature change over time. Instead we have to use the average of the anomalies for each month <ε(m)>. That in turn means we need a reliable way of calculating the anomalies.

ii) Defining the temperature anomaly

The anomalies are the amount by which the temperatures in a given temperature record deviate from a reference value. That reference value is usually taken to be a mean of the monthly temperature data over a particular time interval. Ideally that time interval should be as long as possible so that it is as accurate as possible. However, there are two problems here. 

The first is that, if the temperature records have a strong trend, either upwards or downwards, and you use different time periods to calculate the reference mean temperature of the different records, this will distort the mean temperature trend, particularly if the different temperature records have differing amounts of data. So you really need to use the same time period for all temperature records when calculating their reference temperatures. That means that you generally can't use extremely long time time periods that use all the data from that record, but instead must use shorter time periods (usually 20 or 30 years) for which as many station records as possible have sufficient data. And if a particular temperature record has no data or insufficient data in that time period (say for the period 1961-1990) when many other records do, then that record will have to be excluded from the calculation of the mean temperature trend. If a significant number of long datasets are excluded in this way, then there are ways of repeating the calculation of the mean reference temperature using other time periods in order to include them, but that is a subsidiary problem. Essentially you will end up with multiple mean temperature trends which could then be merged into a single trend through a weighted averaging process based on the number of station records incorporated into each one.

The second problem is that as you move away from the equator, the seasonal variation of the mean temperature increases. As I pointed out above, near the equator typical variations of the mean temperature each month can vary by as little as ±1 °C. However, at latitudes of 50°N (i.e. in Europe or North America) typical variations of the mean temperature each month can exceed ±10 °C. This means that it is more accurate to calculate a mean temperature for each month (so twelve in total), rather than just calculating one overall. These mean temperatures I have referred to in previous posts as the monthly reference temperatures or MRTs.

iii) Choosing a time-frame for the MRTs

In order to determine the temperature trend for a country or region you need to average the temperature anomalies from all of its temperature records. So you need to first calculate the anomalies for each station record. In order to calculate the temperature anomalies you need to first calculate the monthly reference temperatures or MRTs for all twelve months of the year for that record. However, in order to do this with the minimum amount of statistical error you need to consider a number of factors that may influence how you choose your reference period for the MRTs.

The first thing you need to ensure is that the MRTs are calculated over the same time-frame for each temperature record. The reason for this is the the same as was expounded in (ii) above. If the temperature records are of differing lengths, then using different MRTs for each one will have the same effect as using different values of <M> for each month in Eq. 47.3. It will distort the mean temperature trend.

Next, you want the time-frame you use to calculate the MRTs to be as long as possible so that it is as accurate as possible. Unfortunately, because the majority of temperature records tend to be fairly recent with less than 40 years of data, this means that you will lose accuracy in your mean temperature trend due to insufficient temperature records qualifying for the averaging process.

So in order to incorporate as much of the available temperature data as possible into the final mean temperature trend you need to reduce the time-frame, but not reduce it so much that the MRTs are no longer sufficiently accurate. This is basically a compromise between maximizing the time-frame you use for the MRT calculations, and maximizing the amount of data that can then be used in the mean temperature trend calculation. The most effective way to do this is to create a frequency histogram for each month m, where the value for each month is the sum of all the record lengths for station data that have valid data for that month m. So if temperature record i has Li months of data, and δi(m) is a binary function for station i that takes the value 1 if month m in record i has valid data and 0 if it does not, then the monthly data frequency function f(m) will be

 f(m) = ∑i Li δi(m)

(47.4)

An example of such a frequency function is shown below in Fig. 47.1 for data from the Netherlands. The peak in the distribution indicates where a time-frame chosen to determine the MRTs is likely to generate the maximum amount of anomaly temperature data for inclusion in the mean temperature trend.



 Fig. 47.1: The amount of temperature data available from the Netherlands when each month is included in the MRT.

 

The data in Fig. 47.1 above suggests that the optimal 30-year time-frame that allows the most data to be included in the final trend is likely to be around 1975-2010. In fact the time-frame 1976-2005 was eventually chosen (see Post 41). However, there are two other considerations that need to be taken into account before finally settling on a time-frame. 

Ideally you want the overall temperature trend for your time-frame to be close to zero. This is to improve accuracy in the MRT calculations. Unfortunately that is not always possible. In fact it rarely is. This is because the majority of data in most temperature data tends to be fairly recent, as illustrated in Fig. 47.1, but recent data also tends to exhibit the greatest warming trend.

The final problem is the issue of missing or incomplete data. Even some of the best temperature records will have several months of missing data within your chosen MRT time-frame. The way to address this is to set minimum thresholds for the number of months of data that need to be present within the MRT time-frame in order for data from that station to be included in the mean temperature trend.

Based on the above conditions I have generally used the following criteria to determine the MRTs.

1) Select a time-frame of 30 years where there is the most data available. Failing that use a 20 year time-frame.

2) For each of the 12 monthly MRTs, only calculate the MRT if there is at least 40% of the data available within the time-frame (i.e. 12 out of 30 years). For a 20 year time frame increase this to 60% (i.e. 12 out of 20 years). 

3) If the MRT cannot be determined for any of the 12 months in a given record, then all data for that month of the year from that record is excluded for all years.

iv) Calculating the MRTs and the anomalies

The MRT for each month of a given record is calculated by first determining the time-frame for its calculation as set out above in (iii), and then averaging all the available temperature readings for that month within the time-frame. 

To see how this works in practice, consider the case of the temperature record from Volken (Berkeley Earth ID: 92832) in the Netherlands. We have already seen in Fig 47.1 above that the optimal time-frame for calculating the MRTs in the Netherlands is around 1976-2005. This will be the same for all station records in the region. The mean monthly temperatures for Volken are shown in Fig. 47.2 below with data in the MRT reference period (1996-2005) shown in yellow.

 

Fig. 47.2: The raw monthly temperature data for Volken with the data in the MRT time-frame highlighted in yellow.

 

We next find the mean temperature values for each of the twelve months January-December using the yellow data in Fig. 47.2 above. These mean temperatures are listed in Table 47.1 below. These are the MRT values described above.

 

Table 47.1
Month Mean Temperature or MRT (°C)
January
 2.4818
February
 2.9020
March
 6.0305
April
 8.6293
May
 12.9136
June
 15.5573
July
 17.5369
August
 17.4261
September
 14.3748
October
 10.6354
November
 6.0696
December
 3.4268



The MRT values are then subtracted from the raw data in Fig. 47.2 to yield the anomalies for each month. This is shown in Fig. 47.3 below, where the MRTs are plotted repeatedly in green and the anomalies are in red. It therefore follows that adding the red curve in Fig. 47.3 to the green curve in Fig. 47.3 will recreate the original data in Fig. 47.2.

 

Fig. 47.3: The MRT values and the temperature anomalies for Volken.


In the next few posts I will look at the temperature data for a number of different countries in Europe. In each case the temperature anomalies for each station will be calculated using the method outlined here. The most significant differences in the method used from country to country will be in the choice of MRT time-frame (this will normally be 1961-1990 but may be later or earlier) and the length of the time-frame (normally 30 years, but sometime 20 years will be required due to a lack of available data). In each case this will be indicated, as will the reasons for the choices.


Saturday, September 5, 2020

35. South America - temperature trends 0.5°C WARMING

The land area of South America is more than twice that of Australia while its population is more than sixteen times greater. Yet it has fewer high quality temperature records than New South Wales.

Overall South America has about 1000 temperature records, but only 21 have more than 100 years, or 1200 months, of data. Of these long station records, the longest is that of Rio de Janeiro (Berkeley Earth ID: 152852). Its earliest temperature data dates from 1832 and clearly shows that temperatures in the city at that time were higher than today (see Fig. 35.1 below). The average temperature then declined throughout the 19th century before recovering over the last 100 years. This behaviour is not unique to South America. We have seen it in both Australia and New Zealand previously, and if other countries in the Southern Hemisphere had longer records, we might have seen it in many other places as well. 

 

Fig. 35.1: The temperature trend for Rio de Janeiro since 1832. The best fit is applied to the interval 1921-1990 and has a gradient of +2.06 ± 0.15 °C per century. The monthly temperature changes are defined relative to the 1951-2000 monthly averages.


However, the extent to which the Rio data reflects the overall temperature trend in South America is harder to determine. Of the 1000 or so sets of station data from South America, only about 318 have more than 40 years, or 480 months, of data, and as I have shown in previous posts, even this length of data is insufficient to ascertain the recent overall temperature trend, let alone its longer term context. 

The approximate locations of the long and medium stations in South America are shown on the map below. It can be seen that they are fairly evenly spread throughout the continent, but with the Amazon region, not surprisingly, being less well represented. 


Fig. 35.2: The locations of long stations (large squares) and medium stations (small diamonds) in South America. Those stations with a high warming trend are marked in red.


In order to determine the overall temperature trend for South America we need to average the temperature anomalies from all the different stations in the region, as I explained in Post 5. These temperature anomalies are not the actual average monthly temperatures for each location, but the amount by which those average monthly temperatures change relative to a defined reference value for that month. That monthly reference temperature (or MRT), is usually an average of the values for that month over a given period, say 1961-1990. However, as I have pointed out in many previous posts, the way anomaly data used by climate groups like Berkeley Earth is calculated is not quite that straightforward. 

The anomaly data used by climate groups is also subject to adjustments via processes such as homogenization and breakpoint alignment. In homogenization, neighbouring sets of station data are compared and averaged to determine the monthly reference temperature values (MRT) for the target station. Once this homogenized MRT is subtracted from the monthly temperature to yield the anomaly for that month, a number of breakpoint adjustments are then made to different segments of the anomaly data in that dataset, supposedly to correct for bad data and other behaviours seen in the data that appear to be incongruous. The problem with both these interventions is that they are not neutral. Analysis from almost all the previous data I have examined so far in this blog has shown that both these interventions tend to add significant warming to the temperature trends after 1900. The data presented here for South America is no exception.

It is relatively easy to calculate the magnitude of the adjustments made by Berkeley Earth, because conveniently Berkeley Earth list both the adjusted and unadjusted anomaly data in each data file, together with the original raw temperature data. If we average the Berkeley Earth adjusted anomaly data from all the long and medium stations identified in Fig. 35.2 above, the result is the curves shown below in Fig. 35.3.


Fig. 35.3: Temperature trends for all long and medium stations in South America since 1832 derived by aggregating and averaging the Berkeley Earth adjusted data. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1900-1999 and has a gradient of +0.85 ± 0.02 °C/century.


The temperature trends shown in Fig. 35.3 above clearly exhibit a strong warming of more than 1.0 °C after 1890. The other notable point is how well the data in Fig. 35.3 agrees with the official Berkeley Earth version shown in Fig. 35.4 below. This can be verified by comparing the pattern of peaks in the 12-month moving average in each case. This shows that using different weightings for each set of station data when calculating the average is not needed.


Fig. 35.4: The temperature trend for South America since 1850 according to Berkeley Earth.


So, what happens if we perform the same averaging of station data, but use the raw temperature data without homogenization and breakpoint adjustments? This means first constructing the anomaly data by calculating the MRT using only the actual station data. 

Ideally when calculating the MRT values it is best to choose as long a time interval as possible for the reference average so that those values have less uncertainty associated with them. This means that ideally you want to include as many years of data as possible in the calculation of each of the twelve MRT values. But this poses a number of problems.

(i) Different station records generally have different amounts of data.

(ii) Different station records often encompass different epochs.

(iii) Most station records have periods of missing data or gaps in their record. These may be a single month of data, or they could be several years in length, and there are often multiple gaps.

(iv) Different sets of station data have different temperature trends. Moreover, the longer the temperature records, the more the trend can vary over time within that station record, or the greater the difference in the mean temperatures will be at either end of the record.

The result is that you need to compromise by choosing a time interval for the MRT average that maximizes the total number of stations that can be included in the average, reduces the uncertainty in that average, but also addresses the four issues listed above. The solutions to those four problems are as follows:

(i) Use the same length of time interval for the MRT average for all stations. This is normally 20 or 30 years.

(ii) Choose the MRT time interval so that it overlaps with the epochs of as many station records as possible. In the case of South America this was achieved by using the time interval 1971-2000.

(iii) Set a minimum threshold for the number of years of data required for the MRT for that month to be of sufficient quality. For the data analysed here that was set at 40% (i.e. 12 out of a possible 30 years).

(iv) Set the length of time interval for the MRT average to be shorter than the timescale over which most significant temperature trends are seen. This is normally 20 or 30 years.


Fig. 35.5: The temperature trend for South America since 1832. The best fit is applied to the interval 1900-1999 and has a gradient of +0.54 ± 0.05 °C per century. The monthly temperature changes are defined relative to the 1971-2000 monthly averages.


After the MRT has been calculated for each of the twelve months in each station record, these MRT values are then subtracted from the raw temperature data for that station to yield the monthly anomalies. The anomalies from all the stations are then averaged to provide the regional temperature trend. This trend for South America is shown in Fig. 35.5 above.

The data in Fig. 35.5 clearly shows an upward temperature trend since 1920 of about 0.5 °C. This is similar to trends we have seen in other regions such as Australia and New Zealand, but it is much less than the 1.0 °C or so that is expected based on the HadCRUT4 data. However the picture before 1900 is less clear. There is some evidence of higher temperatures in the late 19th century, but the data is not extensive enough to provide definite proof. There are only about a dozen stations in the whole continent with data that dates from before 1880. Nevertheless, there are definite similarities between the data shown here for South America and other Southern Hemisphere data from Australia and New Zealand. The fact that all three regions exhibit similar trends before 1900 and also after 1900 suggests that the higher temperatures seen in Fig. 35.5 before 1900 are probably real.

What is evident, though, is that the temperature rise in the trend based on the raw data shown in Fig. 35.5 is not as severe as that published by Hadley-CRU, or that published by Berkeley Earth and shown in Fig. 35.4 above. The differences between the two sets of data (from Fig. 35.5 and Fig. 35.3) are highlighted in Fig. 35.6 below.


Fig. 35.6: The contribution of Berkeley Earth (BE) adjustments to the anomaly data after smoothing with a 12-month moving average. The linear best fit to the data is for the period 1901-2010 (red line) and the gradient is +0.33 ± 0.02 °C per century. The orange curve represents the contribution made to the BE adjustment curve by breakpoint adjustments only.


What Fig. 35.6 demonstrates is that the adjustments made to the data by Berkeley Earth are (again) not neutral. In this case they add at least 0.4 °C to the warming since about 1900. But, this is not new. Similar impacts have been seen previously on the temperature trends from many other regions in the Southern Hemisphere (see my other country-based and regional blog posts 8, 18-26, 30-34).


Conclusions

1) There has been about 0.5 °C of warming in South America since 1920. This is much less than is claimed by climate groups and the IPCC.

2) There is some evidence of higher temperatures before 1900, similar to those seen in Australia and New Zealand, but it is heavily dependent on only one or two temperature records, principally Rio de Janeiro as shown in Fig. 35.1.

3) Adjustments made to the data by Berkeley Earth have added significant warming to the temperature trend since 1900.


Addendum

The temperature trend shown in Fig. 35.5 above is the result of averaging almost 300 temperature records. While all these records have over 480 months of data, very few extend back beyond 1900. In fact between 1860 and 1900 the number of temperature records involved in the average for the trend varies from 4 up to 18. This implies an uncertainty in the trend in Fig. 35.5 of between 0.25 °C and 0.5 °C, whereas after 1960 this falls to about 0.05 °C. Thus the uncertainty in the trend in 1860 is about ten times greater than in 1980. This is probably reflected in the differing amounts of natural variation in the 5-year moving average temperature trend for those different epochs. 

It should also be noted that the temperature data shown in Fig. 35.5 before 1860 is dominated by the temperature data from Rio de Janeiro shown in Fig. 35.1. Its reliability is therefore questionable.


Fig. 35.7: The number of sets of station data included each month in the temperature trend for South America shown in Fig. 35.5.


Friday, August 28, 2020

34. South Pacific - temperature trends part 2 (east) COOLING

In my previous post I used the temperature data from all the significant temperature records in the region to show that there is no evidence of anthropogenic global warming (AGW) in the western region of the South Pacific. Now I will demonstrate the same for the eastern region.

The eastern region I have defined to be the part of the southern Pacific Ocean between the Pitcairn Islands at a longitude of about 130.1°W and the Pacific coast of South America. This region of the ocean contains far fewer islands than the western portion, and therefore far fewer temperature records. In fact there are only seven station temperature records with more than 480 months of data, of which two are long station records with more than 1200 months. Those latter two are both located on the Chilean islands of Isla Juan Fernandez (Berkeley Earth ID: 11338 and 153937) along with one of the medium records with over 480 months of data (Berkeley Earth ID: 11341). Of the other four medium records, one is from the Pitcairn Islands (Berkeley Earth ID: 155860), one is from San Cristobal in the Galapagos Islands (Berkeley Earth ID: 154642), and two are from the Chilean island of Isla de Pascua, otherwise known as Easter Island (Berkeley Earth ID: 11362 and 153945).


Fig. 34.1: The temperature trend for the eastern South Pacific since 1900. The best fit is applied to the interval 1913-2012 and has a negative gradient of -0.10 ± 0.06 °C per century. The monthly temperature changes are defined relative to the 1951-1970 monthly averages.


The anomalies for each of the seven temperature records used were calculated by subtracting a monthly reference temperature (MRT) from each monthly reading, as described previously. These reference temperatures were calculated by averaging that month's data for the interval 1951-1970. The mean of the seven sets of anomalies is shown above in Fig. 34.1. It can clearly be seen to exhibit a negative temperature trend. In other words, there is no evidence of global warming.


Fig. 34.2: Temperature trends for all long and medium stations in the eastern South Pacific since 1900 derived by aggregating and averaging the Berkeley Earth adjusted data. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1913-2012 and has a gradient of +0.71 ± 0.03 °C/century.


Yet the same calculation using Berkeley Earth adjusted data yields a completely different result. The warming since 1900 is now more than 0.8 °C. This is not a consequence of the data, but of the adjustments made to that data. The sum of those adjustments is illustrated below in Fig. 34.3, and indicates that they amount to a correction to the raw data of at least 0.8 °C since 1900, and possibly even more. The data in Fig. 34.3 also indicates that the vast majority of these adjustments are due to the breakpoint adjustment process rather than homogenization.


Fig. 34.3: The contribution of Berkeley Earth (BE) adjustments to the anomaly data after smoothing with a 12-month moving average. The linear best fit to the data is for the period 1913-2012 (red line) and the gradient is +0.81 ± 0.04 °C per century. The orange curve represents the contribution made to the BE adjustment curve by breakpoint adjustments only.


Conclusions

1) The overall temperature trend in the eastern region of the South Pacific over the last 100 years has been negative (see Fig. 34.1). There is no evidence in the raw temperature records of anthropogenic global warming (AGW) in this region.

2) In contrast, the adjusted temperature data constructed by Berkeley Earth exhibits a strong warming trend in its aggregated data of over 0.7 °C per century since 1900 (see Fig. 34.2).

3) The adjustments made to the raw temperature data by Berkeley Earth equate to a change in the overall temperature trend of more than 0.8 °C per century. Almost all of this is the result of adjustments made using the breakpoint adjustment process (see Fig 34.3).


Addendum

The data in Fig. 34.1 above was calculated by averaging the records of the seven stations listed. However, as three of those stations are in close proximity to each other on Isla Juan Fernandez, and another two are likewise in close proximity on Isla de Pascua, it could be argued that relative weightings of 1/3 and 1/2 respectively should be applied to these stations. It so, then the overall temperature trend will change to that shown below in Fig. 34.4. The principal result here is that the new temperature trend with the station weightings is now even more negative: -0.18 ± 0.07 °C per century.


Fig. 34.4: The temperature trend for the eastern South Pacific since 1900. The best fit is applied to the interval 1913-2012 and has a negative gradient of -0.18 ± 0.07 °C per century. The monthly temperature changes are defined relative to the 1951-1970 monthly averages and local weightings are applied to the different temperature anomalies.


Saturday, August 22, 2020

32. Papua New Guinea - temperature trends 0.4°C WARMING (moderate)

I had thought about combining the temperature data for Papua New Guinea (PNG) with that of Indonesia, just as I did with East Timor (Timor Leste) in the previous post. Like East Timor, PNG shares an island (in this case Papua) with Indonesia, so from that point of view it would be logical. However, in the end I decided there was enough data in Indonesia, and extending the analysis to PNG would not only increase the data analysis complexity, but also the geographical area of coverage, and that would be too much. 

Like Indonesia, PNG has only one long station with a temperature record longer than 1200 month (Port Moresby AP - Berkeley Earth ID: 157418). It also has seven medium stations with records of more than 480 months of temperature data, and there are approximately 30 other shorter records that are too small to be useful. One of the medium stations (Port Moresby - Berkeley Earth ID: 19383) is excluded from the following analysis even though it contains data that suggests temperatures in the late 1800s were up to 1.0 °C higher than in the early 20th century. This is because: a) it is close to another long station (Port Moresby AP - Berkeley Earth ID: 157418) which has longer and more complete data in the 20th century; and b) because it has no data after 1941, and so its monthly reference temperatures (MRTs) cannot be calculated for the same time period (1961-1990) as the other stations. For an explanation of MRTs, and how they are used to calculate the monthly temperature anomaly, see Post 4.


Fig. 32.1: Temperature trend for all long and medium stations in Papua New Guineasince 1900 derived using the Berkeley Earth adjusted data. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1912-1999 and has a gradient of +0.83 ± 0.03 °C/century.


Averaging the Berkeley Earth adjusted anomaly data from the eight long and medium stations yields the temperature trends shown in Fig. 32.1 above. These are very similar to the versions published by Berkeley Earth and shown below in Fig. 32.2, which suggests that the weightings for each station used by Berkeley Earth in their averaging process were fairly equal.

 

 Fig. 32.2: Temperature trend for Papua New Guinea since 1880 according to Berkeley Earth.

 

The high level of agreement between the data in Fig. 32.1 and Fig. 32.2 allows us to repeat the process for the raw anomaly data without the need for different station weighting coefficients. The result is shown below in Fig. 32.3. 

 

Fig. 32.3: The temperature trend for Papua New Guinea since 1900. The best fit is applied to the interval 1912-1999 and has a gradient of 0.44 ± 0.07 °C per century. The temperature changes are relative to the 1961-1990 average.


It can be seen that once again, the temperature trend derived from the raw anomaly data in Fig. 32.3 is significantly different in its degree of warming compared to that derived using the Berkeley Earth adjusted data in Fig. 32.1 and Fig. 32.2. While there are qualitative similarities (the peaks at 1910 and 2000, and the local minimum around 1965), the overall temperature rise seen in the raw data is much less. At worst, the temperature rise seen in the raw data in Fig. 32.3 is less than 0.4 °C, while the 5-year average in 2010 is barely higher than the peaks in the same curve before 1940.

The 5-year average in 2010 is also only 0.3 °C higher than the 80-year average for 1903-1982. This is hardly conclusive evidence of cataclysmic global warming. In fact the 5-year mean in 2010 is less than two standard deviations above the pre-1982 mean. It is, therefore, within the expected range for natural fluctuations for the given timescale of 110 years.

The data in Fig. 32.3 is also noticeably noisier before 1950 than it is after 1950. This is because there are only two temperature records with data before 1950, and only one of those, Port Moresby AP (Berkeley Earth ID: 157418), is reasonably continuous.

A final point of interest is the qualitative similarity between the data for PNG in Fig. 32.3 above, and that for Queensland shown in Fig. 24.4 previously. The biggest difference appears to be the overall temperature rise which is significantly higher in the case of Queensland (0.74 °C per century compared to 0.44 °C per century for PNG).


Fig. 32.4: The contribution of Berkeley Earth (BE) adjustments to the anomaly data after smoothing with a 12-month moving average. The linear best fit to the data is for the period 1904-2012 (red line) and the gradient is +0.34 ± 0.03 °C per century. The orange curve represents the contribution made to the BE adjustment curve by breakpoint adjustments only.


It is clear that the Berkeley Earth adjusted data for PNG results in almost double the temperature rise since 1900 compared to that found using the raw data. The actual difference is shown in Fig. 32.4 above and amounts to about 0.34 °C per century, most of which is due to breakpoint adjustments.


Conclusions

1) Papua New Guinea has experienced a modest temperature rise since 1960 (perhaps 0.5°C), but overall, temperatures have barely risen by more than 0.3 °C since 1900 (see Fig. 32.3).

2) The temperature trend for Papua New Guinea from 1900 to 2013 is broadly similar to that seen in neighbouring countries and regions (e.g. Indonesia, Australia and New Zealand).

3) The fluctuations in temperature for Papua New Guinea appear broadly consistent with natural variability. The magnitude of these temperature changes clearly challenge the current prevailing paradigm regarding anthropogenic global warming of more than 1.0 °C.

4) The adjustments made to the temperature data by Berkeley Earth have once again had a material and significant impact on the overall temperature trend. It is only with the inclusion of these adjustments that the temperature trend for Papua New Guinea resembles that of the IPCC HadCRUT4 temperature record.

5) The lack of data means that the temperature record of Papua New Guinea before 1950 is extremely uncertain. It can only be speculated upon based on similarities with neighbouring countries.

 

Addendum

The maximum number of temperature records used to derive the mean temperature trend in Fig. 32.3 is seven but before 1940 this reduces to two or less (see Fig. 32.5 below). See here for a complete list of all stations in Papua New Guinea.

 

Fig. 32.5: The number of station records included each month in the mean temperature anomaly (MTA) trend for Papua New Guinea in Fig. 32.3.

 

Monday, August 17, 2020

30. Temperature trends in Antarctica - VARIABLE

If there is one region of the planet that is synonymous with climate change, it is probably Antarctica. Climate change, we are told, is melting the ice cap, the glaciers, the ice shelves and the sea ice. As a result penguins may become extinct in 100 years. Or not, because it turns out there are actually a lot more of them than we thought. So what is really happening in Antarctica?

Well, the honest answer is that we don't really know.  Despite being one of the most studied places on the planet, there is virtually no instrumental temperature data from before 1940. The continent has over 260 instrumental temperature records, but most are less than 40 years in length. In fact only about 56 have more than 240 months of data, of a mere 22 have more than 480 months of data. As the following analysis will show, this is insufficient to draw any accurate or definitive conclusions about the current temperature trends for the continent.


Fig. 30.1: A map of Antarctica showing the locations of all the stations with temperature records containing more than 240 months of data.


Part of the problem with analysing the temperature records of Antarctic is the sheer size of the place. It has almost twice the area of Australia, but the weather stations are not evenly distributed. And given its size, it would be inappropriate to simply aggregate trends from opposite sides of the continent, for the same reasons as for Australia; principally, that they are likely to be totally uncorrelated. When looking at the spatial distribution of stations it becomes clear that most are situated on the coast (see Fig. 30.1 above). Those that are inland are usually at altitude, and as I showed in Post 4, the temperatures in the interior of Antarctica are much lower than elsewhere, and have much higher levels of variability. This implies that they should be analysed and aggregated separately.

In addition, the coastal stations appear to exist in three distinct clusters. The most obvious two are the high densities of stations on the peninsula and around the Ross Sea. In contrast, the stations around the Atlantic coast from longitude 45° W to 90° E are more evenly spread. It therefore seems logical to subdivide the stations into four separate groupings: (i) those found on the Antarctic Peninsula; (ii) the interior stations at altitude; (iii) the stations located along the Pacific coast from the Amundsen Sea in the east, to Queen Mary Land in the west via the Ross Sea; (iv) the stations on the Atlantic Coast from 45° W to 90° E. These four groupings of stations are identified in Fig. 30.1 above. 

 

Fig. 30.2: Number of stations active each month that have more than 240 months of data overall.

 

In Post 4 I looked at the three most significant station records for the interior of Antarctica: Amundsen-Scott Base (Berkeley ID - 166900), Vostok (Berkeley ID - 151513) and Byrd Station (Berkeley ID - 166906). The data for Byrd Station was fragmented, while that for both Amundsen-Scott and Vostok indicated negative temperature trends. No other stations in the interior have more than 240 months of data.

Using 240 months as the cutoff, we find that the number of active stations in the other three regions of Antartica that contain this minimum amount of monthly temperature data never exceeds 20, and in the case of the Atlantic coast, it never exceeds 10 (see Fig. 30.2 above). In addition, most of the data is concentrated from 1980 onwards, and only the Antarctic Peninsula has any data before 1950, but even that is miniscule in terms of its total amount.


Fig. 30.3: The mean temperature for the Pacific coast of Antarctica since 1950. The best fit line is fitted to data from 1973-2010 and has an overall trend of 0.55 ± 0.80 °C per century.


If we calculate the mean temperature trend using the data that is available, the results are not great, at least not if you are a firm believer in climate change. The data for the Pacific coast displays a small amount of warming of 0.55 °C per century since 1973 as shown in Fig. 30.3 above (i.e. 0.21 °C in total). The period 1973-2010 was chosen for the best fit calculation because that time-frame is bounded by two peaks in the 5-year moving average. This means that the peaks do not distort the best fit calculation for reasons that I have outlined in the discussion of Fig. 4.7 in Post 4. 

If the best fit in Fig. 30.3 were to be made to all the data, then best fit trend becomes 1.61 °C per century. The dip around 1960 now pulls down the trend line and increases the warming trend, but is this localized dip in the temperature record permanent or just temporary? The answer is that we don't know because there is insufficient data before 1960 to judge.


 
Fig. 30.4: The mean temperature for the Atlantic coast of Antarctica since 1950. The best fit line is fitted to data from 1973-2010 and has an overall negative trend of -0.21 ± 0.60 °C per century.


If we now turn to the Atlantic coast the pattern is the same. The temperature trend is relatively stable from 1970 to 2010 (see Fig. 30.4). If we measure the trend for 1973-2010 in order to compare directly with that for the Pacific coast, we see that the trend is actually slightly negative and equal to -0.21 ± 0.60 °C per century. But again, extending the fitting to all the data changes the trend to a positive one of gradient +0.49 ± 0.31 °C per century. This is, once again a consequence of a dip in temperatures around 1960. This suggests that the temperature fall is real, and not due to measurement errors, but this dip is large enough to completely change the trend from -0.21 °C per century to +0.49 °C per century.

There is one other similarity with the Pacific coast data: the uncertainties in both trends are very large. This is due to the comparatively short time frame for the available data, which illustrates why long temperature records are so valuable. Even 60 years is not long enough.


Fig. 30.5: The mean temperature for the Antarctic Peninsula since 1940. The best fit line is fitted to data from 1973-2010 and has an overall trend of 2.88 ± 0.77 °C per century.


The notable point about the Antarctic Peninsula is that it is the only region of Antarctica where there is clear evidence of a significant warming trend since 1950. But this is no different from what we have seen in Australia and New Zealand, and in this case there is no data before 1940. That means we cannot say whether this warming is new and permanent, or whether, like Australia and New Zealand, it is just a recovery from a temporary cooling phase. In Australia and New Zealand the temperatures in the latter half of the 19th century were just as high as they are now. In the case of Antarctica we just do not know.


Summary

The analysis above allows us to draw the following conclusions.

  1. There has been no warming trend in the interior of Antarctica since 1957 (see Post 4).
  2. The has been no warming trend on the Atlantic coast since 1950, and probably none of any great consequence on the Pacific coast either (see Fig. 30.4 and Fig. 30.3).
  3. The only significant recent warming in Antarctic appears to be around the peninsula (as shown in Fig. 30.5). This warming is, however, no greater than that seen in Australia and New Zealand over the same time period (1950-2010), and that warming was preceded by a cooling of almost equal magnitude (see Post 26 and Post 8).
  4. We have no idea what the temperature trend anywhere in Antarctica was before 1940.


Sunday, August 2, 2020

28. No AGW in Australia? A summary of trends.

 

Fig. 28: 10-year average temperature trends for Australia based on actual raw data (blue curve) and Berkeley Earth adjusted data (orange curve). The gradient of the best fit to the actual raw data (red line) is +0.18 ± 0.02 °C per century. The temperature change is relative to the 1961-1990 average.
 
 
 
My previous ten posts have examined the temperature records of Australia, state by state, and then also examined the combined result. The final results, based on my analytical methods, are summarized as follows.

1) The mean temperatures in Australia since 2000 are at most 0.2 °C higher, and probably less than 0.1 °C higher than those seen in the latter part of the 19th century (see Fig. 26.1).

2) The average temperature in Australia over the course of the entire 20th century was 0.063 °C lower than the equivalent value for the last 50 years of the 19th century.

3) The average temperature in Australia from 1950-1999 was only 0.1 °C higher than the average for the last 50 years of the 19th century.

4) The fluctuations in the temperature of Australia show a scaling behaviour with a fractal dimension of 0.26 (see Fig. 27.2). This suggests that most of the features in the smoothed data, or data averaged over long timescales, are just low frequency noise. Similar effects are seen in the data for most states, and also in the data for New Zealand (see Post 9).

5) The scaling behaviour of the anomalies implies that the 100-year average temperature for Australia would still have fluctuations with a standard deviation of more than 0.10 °C. This is more than the temperature difference observed between the values for the mean temperature of the latter half of the 19th century and that of the latter half of the 20th century. Thus, the temperature rise seen in the latter half of the 20th century is within the range that would be expected based on random chaotic fluctuations.

6) Only Western Australia and Queensland appear to have had noticeably higher temperatures after the year 2000 compared to the late 19th century. This is partly explained by the fact that both states have little or poor data before 1890.

7) The various adjustments made to the individual temperature records by climate groups like Berkeley Earth appear to have had a significant impact on the overall warming trend for Australia when compared with my more simplified (but in my view more justifiable) statistical methodology. This means that the statistical methods used to analyse the data, and their rationale, are of critical importance and need to be thoroughly tested, evaluated, and justified. The first step in doing this should always be to compare the results based on the adjustments with those obtained without the adjustments. That has always been the primary raison d'être of this blog.

8) The overall effect of adjustments made to the individual temperature records of Australia by Berkeley Earth, when compared to my results, has been to partially flatten the curve in Fig. 26.1 before 1900 and to increase the warming trend by up to 0.3 °C after 1900 (see Fig. 26.5). These adjustments are not neutral and completely change the shape of the curve.

9) The overall temperature trend for Australia looks more like a parabola or low frequency oscillation when the raw data is averaged according to my statistical procedure. The effect of the adjustments made to the data by Berkeley Earth is to make the temperature trend look more like a hockey stick (see Fig. 26.4).

Given the shape of the overall instrumental temperature record illustrated in Fig. 26.1, it is difficult to see how this could constitute unambiguous evidence for anthropogenic global warming (AGW). The best (or worst) that can be said about the data is that it is ambiguous. However, it also represents an alternative self-consistent narrative that raises profound questions about the current climate warming zeitgeist.

If my averaging methods for the anomaly data were simplistic to the point of being erroneous, the result would be a mean temperature trend in Fig. 26.1 that was totally uncorrelated with the majority of the individual records from which it was formed. Yet there is no evidence that this is the case. In fact the majority of long temperature records for Australia look very similar to the mean trend shown in Fig. 26.1.

But it is the scaling behaviour that is the killer application. If this phenomenon is real and ubiquitous, then it implies that (almost) everything that is seen in the temperature record is just chaotic noise. The only exception might be the urban heating I described here, and which is clearly important in those parts of the world that have high levels of industry and high population densities. But that is unlikely to be important in most of the Southern Hemisphere.

Friday, July 31, 2020

27. Scaling of temperature anomalies for Australia

In my analysis of temperature data from both New Zealand (Posts 6-10) and Australia (Posts 18-21) I have speculated about the nature of the temperature fluctuations. These fluctuations have not behaved like normal white noise. For a start, when data from multiple stations are averaged, the standard deviation of the fluctuations barely changes. If the fluctuations behaved like white noise then the standard deviation would be expected to decrease by a factor of √N, where N is the number of stations in the average. This does not happen.

Then there is the scaling behaviour. If the data is smoothed with a moving average of length N points, again you would normally expect to see the standard deviation of the smoothed data decrease by a factor of √N compared to the unsmoothed data. Again this does not happen. The standard deviation decreases, but generally only by about a factor of N 0.25. This is important because it essentially predicts how big the fluctuations will be for longer temperature records where each data points represents a longer time interval, such as yearly or decadal averages, rather than the monthly averages that form the basic station records I have been discussing here.

So what do we see for the mean temperature for Australia that I presented in Fig. 26.1 in the last post? In the following discussion I have restricted the analysis to data over a 140 year period from 1874 to 2013. This is because data earlier than this is derived by averaging over much less than 7 states, and will also be based on a much smaller number of individual stations.

Well, firstly the standard deviation of the data in Fig. 26.1 is only 0.627 °C. This is significantly less than that seen in individual temperature records, and in individual states like New South Wales where the value was 1.07 °C. The reason for this decrease is that the temperature record for Australia involves combining records from across the country, and the country is very big. It is, for example over 3600 km from Perth to Brisbane. Yet in Post 11 I showed that the correlation between monthly temperature records for stations that are spatially separated decreases almost linearly with the distance of separation (see Eq. 11.1). In fact, once you get to separations of more than 3000 km, the data in Fig. 11.2(a) suggest station records become completely uncorrelated. This is what appears to be happening here.

The monthly temperature data from Western Australia and Queensland will be almost totally uncorrelated as most of their respective stations are over 3000 km apart. So averaging the two will reduce the standard deviation by a factor of almost √2. Including the other states in the average could increase the reduction factor to √7, but this will be mitigated by the fact that the distances between those states are much less and so their correlations will be greater. The net result is a compromise with the standard deviation appearing to decrease by about 40% compared to the individual state values.

The second point to note is that the fluctuations in the mean temperature for Australia in Fig. 26.1 appear to conform to a Gaussian noise spectrum. This is confirmed below in Fig. 27.1.



Fig. 27.1: The distribution of anomaly values for the mean temperature record for Australia (blue curve), together with the predicted Gaussian distribution for a standard deviation of 0.627 °C.


However, these fluctuations are not white noise. If we smooth the data with different moving averages of size N months, and then recalculate the standard deviation, we get the data shown in Fig. 27.2 below. This is the scaling behaviour I described in the second paragraph above. For a more detailed explanation of its methodology, see Post 17.



Fig. 27.2: The change in standard deviation of the mean temperature anomaly for Australia (see Fig. 26.1) after smoothing with a moving average of size N. The gradient of the best fit line is -0.256 ± 0.003 and R2 = 0.9993


The two significant features of the data in Fig. 27.2 are the gradient of the linear regression best fit line and the magnitude of the residual for the data relative to that line. The gradient is -0.256 ± 0.003 while the rms (root mean square) residual is 2.7% of the standard deviation of the y-values, the residuals being the vertical distance from the data point to the best fit line. This gives a value for R2 of 0.9993, indicating a very good fit to the data.

The rms residual of 2.7% is incredibly low compared to previously determined values for individual states, while the gradient is incredibly close to -1/4. These two results may not be coincidental, and hint at the existence of a fundamental truth within the data, that these temperature records are fractal in nature, with the patterns of fluctuations over different timescales exhibiting strong self-similarity. If so, then this implies even 100-year mean temperatures would exhibit fluctuations with a standard deviation of over 0.1 °C and a range of over 0.4 °C. It would also suggest that changes of more than 0.5 °C in the average temperature of different centuries would be commonplace over the course of millenia. It should be noted that the data in Fig. 26.1 in the last post indicates that the average temperature in Australia over the whole of the 20th century was actually 0.063 °C less than that for the last 50 years of the 19th century.

So, are all the instrumental temperature records and their averages fractals? Do they exhibit self-similarity with a fractal dimension of 0.25 as I have suggested previously? Or is the data just white noise on an oscillating background as the data from South Australia might suggest? The answer is, it is too early to tell. We need more data and longer datasets. What we can say is that the temperature trend for Australia since 1853 in Fig. 26.1 is not a simple hockey stick.

Tuesday, July 28, 2020

25. A summary of temperature trends in Australia

In the seven posts previous to this I analysed the temperature trends in each of the seven major Australian states (ACT was combined with NSW) since instrumental temperature records began in about 1840. The results are summarized below.

In the following graphs the blue curve is the 10-year average temperature for the state relative to the decade 1991-2000 based on the actual unadjusted raw temperature data. The red line is the best fit to that data for the 100 year interval 1901-2000. The orange curve is the trend based on Berkeley Earth adjusted data. This is also defined relative to its mean for the decade 1991-2000.



Fig. 25.1: Temperature trends for NSW. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.08 ± 0.11 °C per century.




Fig. 25.2: Temperature trends for Victoria. The gradient of the best fit line is -0.04 ± 0.09 °C per century.




Fig. 25.3: Temperature trends for Tasmania. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.72 ± 0.11 °C per century.




Fig. 25.4: Temperature trends for South Australia. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.40 ± 0.11 °C per century.




Fig. 25.5: Temperature trends for Western Australia. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.76 ± 0.11 °C per century.




Fig. 25.6: Temperature trends for Northern Territory. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.09 ± 0.09 °C per century.




Fig. 25.7: Temperature trends for Queensland. The gradient of the best fit line is 0.69 ± 0.13 °C per century.




Conclusions

1) The Berkeley Earth adjusted data trends appear to closely follow the actual data trends for the period after 1970. However, before 1970 the two trends often diverge significantly.

2) Even after divergence, the Berkeley Earth adjusted data trend has almost identical features to the corresponding actual data trend. These features include the patterns of peaks, and the large changes in gradient at similar points in time. In fact the adjusted and unadjusted trend lines appear to show near identical instances of abrupt discontinuities and rapid temperature changes at various points along their respective records.

3) Linear regression fits to temperature record data cannot adequately represent the complexity of the data. For example, a 100-year best fit to the NSW data in Fig. 25.1 yields a gradient of 0.08 °C per century for the period 1901-2000, yet for the interval 1881-1980 this changes to -0.41 ± 0.11 °C per century. Likewise, changing the interval of the best fit for Northern Territory to 1886-1985 also changes the gradient to -0.41 ± 0.11 °C per century, while a best fit interval of 1871-1970 for South Australia results in a gradient of -0.60 ± 0.12 °C per century. In other words, the gradient of the best fit line depends strongly on the measurement interval chosen for the best fit.

4) The temperature trends based on actual data (not the Berkeley Earth adjusted data) suggest that for most states, except maybe Queensland, average temperatures in the latter part of the 20th century were lower than those in the latter part of the 19th century.

5) In most states the majority of any climatic warming has occurred after 1980.


Links to all posts with my original analysis are listed below or on the sidebar.

New South Wales (and ACT)

Victoria

Tasmania

South Australia

Western Australia

Northern Territory

Queensland


Monday, July 27, 2020

24. Queensland - temperature trends 0.7°C WARMING


i) Weather station quality and distribution

Queensland is the second largest state by area in Australia, but only the third largest by population. Given that the provision of weather station records around the world appears to broadly correlate with a combination of population and GDP, one would therefore expect Queensland to have more temperature records than smaller states such as Tasmania, South Australia and Northern Territory, but less than states with larger populations such as Victoria and New South Wales (NSW). This is broadly the case, although not in the case of Victoria.

Queensland has 112 stations with over 480 months of data (medium stations), of which 28 are long stations with more than 1200 months of data. This is not as extensive as NSW but more than Victoria. However, while Victoria has fewer stations in total, those long stations that it does have tend to have longer records. The major deficiency of the Queensland temperature records is that none pre-date 1887.



Fig. 24.1: The locations of long stations (large squares) and medium stations (small diamonds) in Queensland. Those stations with a high warming trend since 1887 are marked in red.


If we look at the distribution of weather stations in Queensland (see Fig. 24.1 above) we see that it is fairly even. There is a higher concentration around Brisbane and the Coral Sea coast compared to inland, but the coverage is generally fairly good, if a little sparse around the border with South Australia.


ii) The Berkeley Earth (BE) mean temperature trend

As the stations in Queensland are fairly evenly distributed (see Fig. 24.1 above), it means weighting coefficients based on the local station density are not necessary when combing stations into a regional average. This can be seen when averaging all the Berkeley Earth adjusted anomalies for each month. The resulting overall trend that is produced using a simple averaging process for that data (and plotted in Fig. 24.2) is very similar to that claimed by Berkeley Earth using their weighted averaging process (see Fig. 24.3).




Fig. 24.2: Temperature trend for all long and medium stations in Queensland since 1887 derived using the Berkeley Earth adjusted data. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1951-2003 and has a gradient of +1.74 ± 0.14 °C per century.


The Berkeley Earth trend in Fig. 24.2 above is my reconstruction of the Berkeley Earth adjusted trend. It was derived simply by averaging the adjusted anomalies for all long and medium stations. These adjusted anomalies were found in the data files for each station on the Berkeley Earth site. An example for Brisbane Regional Office Roof (Berkeley Earth ID: 152224) is found here. The adjusted anomaly data is in the 8th column. The raw temperature data is in the 3rd column.

The temperature trend in Fig. 24.2 clearly exhibits a period of stability from 1880 up to 1950, followed by a much stronger warming phase. This is replicated in the official Berkeley Earth version shown in Fig. 24.3 below, the original online version of which can be found here.

It is apparent that most of the prominent features (i.e. major peaks and troughs) displayed by both the 12-month moving average and the 10-year moving average for my reconstruction from the Berkeley Earth adjusted anomalies (shown in Fig. 24.2 above) correspond to similar features at almost identical times in the official Berkeley Earth trend shown below in Fig. 24.3. This implies that only a simple average of the data from Queensland is necessary in order to determine the overall trend for the region, and no station weighting (either based on their area of coverage or statistical significance) is needed.



Fig. 24.3: Temperature trend for Queensland since 1840 according to Berkeley Earth.


The degree of agreement between the data in Fig. 24.2 and Fig. 24.3 also suggests that the trend of the warming period in Fig. 24.2 above, which is approximately 1.74 ± 0.14 °C per century and denoted by the red line, will also correspond to the warming trend post-1920 in Fig. 24.3. This warming trend equates to a total warming since 1951 of about 1.0 °C. If we look at the raw temperature data though (rather than the Berkeley Earth adjusted data), we get a slightly different picture.


iii) Temperature trend based on long and medium station records

In this section I have applied the same simple averaging process to the raw temperature anomalies as was deployed in the last section for the Berkeley Earth adjusted anomalies. The raw anomalies for each dataset were derived by subtracting the monthly reference temperature (MRT) for that dataset from each monthly reading in that dataset. The 12 different MRTs were derived by averaging the temperature for each month in the dataset over the period 1961-1990. Then the mean anomaly for each month was determined by averaging all the values for that month from the different station datasets. The result is the regional monthly average shown in Fig. 24.4 below.



Fig. 24.4: Temperature trend for long and medium stations in Queensland since 1887. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1901-2004 and has a gradient of 0.74 ± 0.08 °C per century.


The temperature trend in Fig. 24.4 is clearly positive over the entire time-frame, although the upward trend is more pronounced after 1950. This is different from the trend for all the other states in Australia, most of which exhibited a clear downward temperature trend before 1940. This difference may be due to the lack of data in Queensland before 1890, or it may be the result of regional variation. It should also be noted though that the trend for Queensland in Fig. 24.4 is very similar to that found for South Australia from 1900 onwards (see Fig. 21.5 here). Overall, the trend in Fig. 24.4 amounts to a total temperature rise since 1890 of 0.89 °C. This is slightly less than that seen for the Berkeley Earth adjusted data in Fig. 24.2.


iv) Breakpoints and other adjustments

Subtracting the mean temperature anomaly shown in Fig. 24.4 from the Berkeley Earth version derived using adjusted anomalies yields the data in Fig. 24.5 below.



Fig. 24.5: The difference between the raw anomaly data in Fig. 23.4 and Berkeley Earth adjusted anomaly data, together with a linear best fit for the period 1901-2010 (red line). The gradient of the best fit line is +0.02 ± 0.04 °C per century. The yellow curve represents the contribution made to the difference data by breakpoint adjustments.


The data in Fig. 24.5 appears to indicate that the Berkeley Earth adjustments are more or less neutral. This is not true, for while the overall contribution to the trend curve is minimal, there are within this two separate contributions which are not.

The first is for the period 1887-1950. Here the adjustments raise the temperatures before 1990, thereby flattening the curve. Then after 1951 the contribution is to increase the slope. The slope of the adjustments after 1951 is +0.15 ± 0.09 °C per century, while before 1951 it is -0.42 ± 0.09 °C.



Fig. 24.6: The contribution of Berkeley Earth adjustments to the anomaly data after smoothing with a 12-month moving average. The linear best fit to the data is for the period 1901-2010 (red line) and the gradient is +0.02 ± 0.04 °C per century. The orange curve represents the contribution made to the adjustment curve by breakpoint adjustments only.


The significant feature of the total adjustment data in Fig. 24.5 (the blue curve with black markers) is the amount of noise it contains, amounting to fluctuations of up to ±0.5 °C. Remarkably, a 12-month moving average completely removes this noise. This implies that the fluctuations are not random, but are periodic, with a period of 12 months. The obvious source of these fluctuations is the difference in the MRT between the values I have derived in my calculation of the temperature anomaly, and the homogenized values used by Berkeley Earth that also rely on data from neighbouring station records.


v) Conclusions

1) Queensland is the only state in Australia that exhibits a significant warming trend.

2) It is also the only state with no evidence of warming before 1890. That is because it is the only state with no significant data before 1890 (other than ACT).

3) The total temperature rise since 1890 is less than 0.9 °C.