149: Portugal, Spain and France - a comparison

In Post 138 I compared the temperature trends of the Scandinavian countries to see it there were any similarities. There were. In fact there was almost perfect agreement between the 5-year average trends of Norway, Sweden and Finland as far back as 1900 (see Fig. 138.3). As both Norway and Sweden had about twenty sets of station data that went back to 1900 and Finland had about ten, this demonstrated that averaging over a large number of independent data sets eliminates most measurements errors: a consequence of regression towards the mean.

In Post 144 I repeated this procedure for trends from Ireland, Scotland and England and obtained a similar result (see Fig. 144.3), although the trend for England differed slightly from the other two due to its greater urbanization. This demonstrates that neighbouring regions should have similar climates, or at least they should experience similar changes to their climates. So is this also the case for Portugal, Spain and France? I ask this because the results from Post 146 suggest that before 1980 the climate of Spain was cooling while Post 145 suggests that that of Portugal was warming. Well, the results in Fig. 149.1 below show that in fact the temperature trends of Spain and Portugal are very well correlated as far back as 1940, then they diverge. France, on the other hand, is only very weakly correlated to both Spain and Portugal.

Fig. 149.1: A comparison of the 5-year average temperature trends since 1800 for Portugal (green), Spain (red) and France (blue). The two upper trends are offset by +2°C for clarity and the bottom two trends are offset by -2°C.

This discrepancy can be explained in part by the number of stations contributing to the mean temperature anomaly (MTA) of each country per month (see Fig. 149.2 below). Before 1940 there are only two stations contributing to the Portugal MTA, which is probably why it diverges from the Spain MTA which consistently has over ten contributing stations. However, this cannot fully explain the poor correlation of the French data to that of either Spain or Portugal, even though France also has a low number of stations before 1940. The issue here is that the France MTA has a high number of contributing stations after 1960, as do Spain and Portugal, and yet its correlation to both of their MTAs is still poor after 1960. That said, its overall trend since 1860 does follow that of Portugal quite closely.

Fig. 149.2: The number of station records included each month in the averaging for the mean temperature trends of each country in Fig. 149.1.

It should be remembered, though, that the MTAs of both Portugal and France before 1940 are strongly dependent on only two or three sets of station data, and in both cases most of these stations are located in the biggest cities: Paris, Marseille, Lisbon and Porto. These four stations also all appear to exhibit severe continuous warming since 1900 consistent with the effect of urban heat islands. In which case the similarity between the MTA trends of Portugal and France before 1940 may simply be a consequence of parallel economic development in their largest cities.

Instead these comparisons suggest that France may actually have a completely different climate to the Iberian Peninsula even though it is its closest neighbour. The reason for this may be down to geography and the influence of the Pyrenees mountain range at the border that effectively insulates one region from the other.