Whereas France only has four long stations with over 1200 months of data, Italy has at least twelve long stations, most with data stretching back over two hundred years. This means it is possible to determine with a high degree of certainty the extent of climate change in Italy as far back as 1820. What this climate data shows is that the climate of Italy was stable for almost two hundred years up until 1980. Then over the last forty years it has warmed by about 1°C.
In addition to its twelve long stations, Italy also has 81 medium stations with over 480 months of data (for a full list see here). The locations of these 93 stations are shown on the map in Fig. 148.1 below. While the stations are generally spread evenly, there is a higher concentration of long stations in the north of the country compared to the south, and some clustering around Milan, Venice and Rome.
Fig. 148.1: The (approximate) locations of the 93 longest weather station records in Italy. Those stations with a high warming trend between 1911 and 2010 are marked in red while those with a cooling or stable trend are marked in blue. Those denoted with squares are long stations with over 1200 months of data, while diamonds denote medium stations with more than 480 months of data.
In order to quantify the changes to the climate of Italy the temperature anomalies for all stations with over 480 months of data before 2014 were determined and averaged. This was done using the usual method as outlined in Post 47 and involved first calculating the temperature anomaly each month for each station relative to its monthly reference temperature (MRT), and then averaging those anomalies to determine the mean temperature anomaly (MTA) for the whole country for each month. The MRTs for each station in Italy were calculated using the same 30-year period, namely from 1961 to 1990.
The resulting MTA is shown as a time series in Fig. 148.2 below and clearly shows that temperatures were stable for over two hundred years up until 1980. Then they appear to increase rapidly by about 1.0°C over thirty years. That said, the change is comparable in size and speed to natural variations seen in earlier parts of the trend such as in 1940. On the other hand the MTA after 1980 is based on data from many more stations (up to ninety) and so is likely to be more accurate.
Fig. 148.2: The mean temperature change for Italy since 1740 relative to the 1961-1990 monthly averages. The best fit is applied to the monthly mean data from 1881 to 1980 and has a slight positive gradient of +0.03 ± 0.12 °C per century.
The total number of stations included in the MTA in Fig. 148.2 each month is shown in Fig. 148.3 below. The peak in the frequency around 1970 suggests that the 1961-1990 interval was indeed the most appropriate to use for the MRTs. It also indicates that data from about ten stations were used to calculate the MTA for almost every month back to 1820. As fifteen stations appears to the minimum number needed to provide an accurate MTA, this suggests that the trend in Fig. 148.2 is reliable at least as far back as 1820.
Fig. 148.3: The number of station records included each month in the mean temperature anomaly (MTA) trend for Italy in Fig. 148.2.
If we next consider the change in temperature based on Berkeley Earth (BE) adjusted data we get the MTA data in Fig. 148.4 below. This again was determined by averaging each month the anomalies from the 93 longest stations but here the picture is slightly different from that depicted in Fig. 148.2. Instead of a stable MTA we see a positive trend of over 0.5°C per century suggesting that the climate was warming before 1980. This clearly contradicts the raw data in Fig. 148.2.
Fig. 148.4: Temperature trends for Italy based on Berkeley Earth adjusted data. The best fit linear trend line (in red) is for the period 1881-1980 and has a positive gradient of +0.53 ± 0.04°C/century.
But if we next compare the curves in Fig. 148.4 with those from the published Berkeley Earth (BE) version for Italy shown in Fig. 148.5 below, we see that there is excellent agreement between the two sets of data at least as far back as 1770. This indicates that the simple averaging of adjusted anomalies used to generate the BE MTA in Fig. 148.4 is as effective and accurate as the more complex gridding method used by Berkeley Earth in Fig. 148.5. In which case simple averaging should be just as effective and accurate in generating the MTA using raw unadjusted data in Fig. 148.2.
Fig. 148.5: The temperature trend for Italy since 1750 according to Berkeley Earth.
The differences between the MTA in Fig. 148.2 and the BE versions using adjusted data in Fig. 148.4 are instead mainly due to the data processing procedures used by Berkeley Earth. These include homogenization, gridding, Kriging and most significantly breakpoint adjustments. These lead to changes to the original temperature data, the magnitude of these adjustments being the difference in the MTA values seen in Fig. 148.2 and Fig. 148.4. The magnitudes of these adjustments are shown graphically in Fig. 148.6 below. The blue curve is the difference in MTA values between adjusted (Fig. 148.4) and unadjusted data (Fig. 148.2), while the orange curve is the contribution to those adjustments arising solely from breakpoint adjustments. Between 1880 and 1980 both are considerable with the former leading to an additional warming since 1880 of over 0.5°C.
Fig. 148.6: The contribution of Berkeley Earth (BE) adjustments to the anomaly data in Fig. 148.4 after smoothing with a 12-month moving average. The blue curve represents the total BE adjustments including those from homogenization. The linear best fit (red line) to these adjustments for the period 1881-1980 has a positive gradient of +0.510 ± 0.009 °C per century. The orange curve shows the contribution just from breakpoint adjustments.
The overall impact of the BE adjustments can be seen more clearly if we compare the 5-year averages for the raw data (from Fig. 148.2) and the BE adjusted data (from Fig. 148.4). This comparison is shown in Fig. 148.7 below. It clearly shows that the trend based on adjusted data (red curve) exhibits considerably more warming since 1840 but slightly less since 1990.
Fig. 148.7: The 5-year mean temperature change for Italy since 1740 based on the original raw data from Fig. 148.2 (in blue) and the Berkeley Earth adjusted data from Fig. 148.4 (in red).
Summary
The raw unadjusted temperature data for Italy clearly shows that the climate was stable from 1780 to 1980 (see Fig. 148.2).
In contrast, the BE adjusted data claims that the climate first cooled and then warmed by 0.5°C from 1880 to 1980 (see Fig. 148.4).
After 1980 the climate has clearly warmed by about 1°C but this is still only of the same magnitude as the natural variations in the climate, so it may be too early to state definitively how much of the warming is permanent and how much more is still to come.
Acronyms
BE = Berkeley Earth.
MRT = monthly reference temperature (see Post 47).
MTA = mean temperature anomaly.
Long station = a station with over 1200 months (100 years) of data before 2014.
Medium station = a station with over 480 months (40 years) of data before 2014.
List of all stations in Italy with links to their raw data files.
No comments:
Post a Comment