In my previous post I explained the concept of the urban heat island (UHI). Unfortunately, finding clear examples in the global temperature records is not so easy. This is not because they don't exist, but because to demonstrate their existence beyond a reasonable doubt requires good data for both the urban area and the wider region within which the UHI sits.
In the case of the urban data, this needs to be from a station that is located in the heart of the urban area and not on its perimeter such as at the local airport. Finding datasets from such locations is a lot harder than one might think because most weather stations are deliberately sited away from the centre of urban areas. Then the dataset needs to be sufficiently long with no gaps in the record in order for it to exhibit a definite trend over time.
In the case of the regional data, this too needs to be based on long datasets with no gaps in their records. But in addition, a large number of these datasets are needed in order to establish an accurate trend for the region.
Satisfying these criteria is particularly difficult in the Southern Hemisphere where the data for most countries other than Australia is not particularly good. Nevertheless, I have identified six examples in the Southern Hemisphere so far (excluding Brazil which I have yet to examine in detail) where the quality of the temperature data for the UHI and its host country or state is sufficient to detect unambiguous differences in their temperature trends. Over the following six posts, including this one, I will examine each of these six examples in turn. So for Exhibit #1 I give you Sydney in New South Wales (NSW), Australia.
The city of Sydney has a population of about 5.3 million. That means that 65% of the New South Wales (NSW) population of 8.2 million live in Sydney even though Sydney accounts for only 1.5% of the area of NSW. It is not really surprising then that the temperature trends for Sydney and NSW over the last 100 years are markedly different. For while NSW has barely warmed at all in the last 140 years, Sydney has warmed by almost 2°C (see Fig. 128.1 below).
Fig. 128.1: The change to the 5-year average temperatures of Sydney (red curve) and New South Wales (blue curve) since 1900.
In Post 18 I examined the temperature trends for New South Wales. The mean temperature change since 1880 is shown in Fig. 128.2 below and it indicates that NSW has exhibited no significant warming. In fact the best fit for 1886-2005 indicates a temperature rise of less than 0.12°C in 120 years while the 5-year average suggests a rise of about 0.25°C.
Fig. 128.2: The mean temperature change for New South Wales since 1880 relative to the 1965-1994 monthly averages. The best fit is applied to the monthly mean data from 1886 to 2005 and has a slight positive gradient of +0.099 ± 0.077 °C per century.
The mean temperature anomaly (MTA) for NSW shown in Fig. 128.2 above is the result of averaging monthly temperature anomalies from over one hundred stations as Fig. 128.3 below demonstrates (see here for a list). However, before 1880 there are less than twenty available stations so the MTA is less reliable and more prone to error from statistical variability. For more details and analysis of the complete data for NSW see Post 18.
Fig. 128.3: The number of station records included each month in the mean temperature anomaly (MTA) trend for New South Wales in Fig. 128.2.
One of the oldest weather stations in NSW is Sydney Observatory Hill (Berkeley Earth ID: 151986). It is located in the heart of Sydney, south of the opera house and harbour, and has continuous data stretching back as far as 1859. It is also the only major station within 20 km of the city centre, hence its significance as a case study of the urban heat island (UHI) effect.
In contrast to the rest of NSW, Sydney Observatory Hill shows significant and continuous warming since 1880 (see Fig. 128.4 below). The best fit for 1886-2005 indicates a temperature rise of more than 1.2°C in 120 years while the 5-year average suggests a rise of over 1.5°C.
Fig. 128.4: The mean temperature change for Sydney Observatory Hill since 1880 relative to its 1965-1994 monthly averages. The best fit is applied to the monthly mean data from 1886 to 2005 and has a positive gradient of +1.01 ± 0.08 °C per century.
Summary
The following temperature changes were observed from 1886 to 2005.
NSW: 0.25°C (trend 0.12°C).
Sydney: 1.5°C (trend 1.2°C).
So Sydney has warmed by at least 1°C more than NSW, or up to ten times faster. A classic UHI!
No comments:
Post a Comment